DOUBT, DECEPTION AND TRUTH. THE PHOTOGRAPHY OF JOAN FONTCUBERTA

A lie as a natural instinct of photography.

February 02, 2021
Leonov, Nikolayev, Istochnikov, Rozhdestvensky, Beregovoi y Shatalov. Sputnik (1997) de Joan Fontcuberta

Deception and, through doubt, truthfulness. The main theme developed by Joan Fontcuberta (February 24, 1955, Barcelona), both in his artistic work and in his essays, is questioning the veracity of photography.

Fontcuberta, a university professor, essayist, critic and promoter of photography, experiences his childhood and adolescence between the graphic studio and the photographic laboratory of his father's advertising agency and reading graphic comics such as “Hazañas Bélicas” (1). The latter will have been what prompted him to investigate the sincerity of things and the first, the justification for which he expressed his views through photography.

As an adult, in Spain, in a political climate full of repression, authoritarianism, propaganda and censorship, he studied Information Sciences. In this context, his interest in pedagogical value and activism in politics grows, which will accompany him throughout his entire career, having his first exhibition in an art gallery at the young age of 17.

 

The story of cosmonaut Ivan Istochnikov and the Soyus 2 Odyssey.

USSR. United States. Space race. Who will rule the space? On October 26, 1968, a meteorite struck the Soviet Soyus 2 spacecraft. According to official sources, that ship was remotely driven with no crew on board except for the dog Kloka. Private information, later declassified, reveals that the spacecraft was piloted by cosmonaut Ivan Istochnikov.

 

The name of this last character is nothing more and nothing less than the literal translation in russian by Joan Fontcuberta. Istochnikov, an invented character to whom he also lends his face in this story of images intermingled with manipulated documents, fictions and realities. Sputnik, perhaps the artist's most famous work, makes explicit how easily the media are capable of manipulating us.

Do not get carried away so easily, the purpose of Fontcuberta's work is not to lie. But the unraveling of the hidden mechanisms in the handling of information. Through parodies, the author seeks to activate the spectator's illusion by interposing it against palimpsests of photographic intervention.

Elements such as truth are substantial in his artistic production. Fontcuberta's works are a perfect example of the transfer of photography as document-message (passive spectator) to document-conversation (active spectator).

In times of Fake News and Post-truth, Fontcuberta invites us since the beginning of his career to distrust images and appeal to a critical conscience. He shares his personality, his skepticism, to be suspicious of the pre-established. For him, the image as well as the writing are fiction by nature. Their task is to be an understandable representation of a reality. There is possibly no better example of photography criticism as evidence of reality than the work of the Catalan artist, Joan Fontcuberta.

 

Among the sources that fed this article is this unmissable interview by the Argentine cultural journalist María Paula Zacharías with Joan Fontcuberta in the context of last year's BAphoto fair.

LiveTalks is a series of interviews to artists, collectors and art agents produced by Pinta Group. This LiveTalk and many more are available in their YouTube’s channel

eZ debug

Timing: Feb 01 2026 13:46:10
Script start
Timing: Feb 01 2026 13:46:10
Module start 'content'
Timing: Feb 01 2026 13:46:10
Module end 'content'
Timing: Feb 01 2026 13:46:10
Script end

Main resources:

Total runtime0.0620 sec
Peak memory usage4,352.0000 KB
Database Queries71

Timing points:

CheckpointStart (sec)Duration (sec)Memory at start (KB)Memory used (KB)
Script start 0.00000.0070 911.5313607.5391
Module start 'content' 0.00700.0076 1,519.0703618.6641
Module end 'content' 0.01460.0472 2,137.73441,704.7031
Script end 0.0618  3,842.4375 

Time accumulators:

 Accumulator Duration (sec) Duration (%) Count Average (sec)
Ini load
Load cache0.00253.9715150.0002
Mysql Total
Database connection0.00071.189310.0007
Mysqli_queries0.014924.0370710.0002
Looping result0.00081.2812710.0000
TS translator
TS init0.00162.569430.0005
TS cache load0.00121.873830.0004
TS context load0.00101.605630.0003
Template Total0.046374.810.0463
Template load0.00132.040010.0013
Template processing0.045172.718810.0451
Template load and register function0.00010.187010.0001
Override
Cache load0.00071.070020.0003
Sytem overhead
Fetch class attribute name0.00050.849210.0005
Fetch class attribute can translate value0.00000.054610.0000
class_abstraction
Instantiating content class attribute0.00000.019610.0000
XML
Image XML parsing0.00162.529010.0016
states
state_id_array0.00101.597950.0002
state_identifier_array0.00101.665650.0002
General
dbfile0.00477.6124220.0002
String conversion0.00010.211620.0001
Note: percentages do not add up to 100% because some accumulators overlap

Time used to render debug report: 0.0003 secs